deploymentGroup does not obey !identifiers hierarchical

[zeljkot]

Expected

It should be allowed that deploymentGroups in different deploymentEnvironements have non-unique identifiers, as they are part of the deploymentEnvironement scope.

Actual

Non-unique identifiers generate an error.

Steps to reproduce

workspace {

    !identifiers hierarchical

    model {

        p = person "Person"

        ss = softwareSystem "My system" {
            tags "styled"

            group "first" {

                ca = container "Container A" {
                    c1 = component "Component A1"
                    c2 = component "Component A2"
                }
                cb = container "Container B" {
                    c1 = component "Component B1"
                    c2 = component "Component B2"
                }
            }
            cc = container "Container C" {
                c1 = component "Component C1"
                c2 = component "Component C2"
            }
            cd = container "Container D" {
                c1 = component "Component D1"
                c2 = component "Component D2"
            }
        }

        de1 = deploymentEnvironment "DeploymentAlpha" {
            dg1 = deploymentGroup "DG1"
            dg2 = deploymentGroup "DG2"

            deploymentNode "Node X" {
                containerInstance ss.ca "" "styled"
                containerInstance ss.cb
            }
            deploymentNode "Node Y" {
                containerInstance ss.cc
                containerInstance ss.cd
                infrastructureNode "Infra" "" "styled"
            }
        }

        de2 = deploymentEnvironment "DeploymentBeta" {
            dg1 = deploymentGroup "DG1"
            dg2 = deploymentGroup "DG2"

            deploymentNode "Node X" {
                containerInstance ss.ca "" "styled"
                containerInstance ss.cb
            }
            deploymentNode "Node Y" {
                containerInstance ss.cc
                containerInstance ss.cd
                infrastructureNode "Infra" "" "styled"
            }
        }

        p -> ss.ca.c1
    }

}

Version/build information

c6b6367582b0 2 weeks ago

Severity

Minor

Priority

Low (I have no budget and there's no rush, please fix this for free)

More information

No response

[simonbrowndotje]

Simpler example:

workspace {

    !identifiers hierarchical

    model {
        deploymentEnvironment "Deployment Environment 1" {
            dg1 = deploymentGroup "Deployment Group 1"
            dg2 = deploymentGroup "Deployment Group 2"
        }

        deploymentEnvironment "Deployment Environment 2" {
            dg1 = deploymentGroup "Deployment Group 1"
            dg2 = deploymentGroup "Deployment Group 2"
        }
    }

}