[FR] musl/AlpineLinux support

[ITwrx]

Using the curl/wget install instructions fails on musl/alpine linux. I figured it would, but i wanted to see what happened.

~/Downloads $ wget -qO - https://nim-lang.org/choosenim/init.sh | sh
choosenim-init: Downloading choosenim-0.8.9_linux_amd64
sh: /tmp/choosenim-0.8.9_linux_amd64: not found

/tmp/choosenim-0.8.9_linux_amd64 exists

Tried to build choosenim from source, but it can't build nimble from source, so that fails too. The nim package in alpine is also out of date, so i'm stuck on 2.0.4 for any alpine/musl targets, which is a production-grade problem for me.

Thanks

[SpotlightKid]

What error(s) do you get when you try to build choosenim from source?

[ITwrx]

~/Downloads/choosenim-0.8.9 $ nimble install
  Verifying dependencies for choosenim@0.8.9
 Installing https://github.com/nim-lang/sat@any version
Downloading https://github.com/nim-lang/sat using git
   Warning: The package has no tagged releases, downloading HEAD instead.
  Verifying dependencies for sat@0.1.0
 Installing sat@0.1.0
  Success:  sat installed successfully.
 Installing nimble@#ed0b6ee
Downloading https://github.com/nim-lang/nimble using git
  Verifying dependencies for nimble@0.14.2
     Info:  Dependency on sat@any version already satisfied
  Verifying dependencies for sat@0.1.0
 Installing checksums@any version
Downloading https://github.com/nim-lang/checksums using git
  Verifying dependencies for checksums@0.2.1
 Installing checksums@0.2.1
  Success:  checksums installed successfully.
 Installing nimble@0.14.2
   Building nimble/nimble using c backend
/tmp/nimble_4649/githubcom_nimlangnimble_#ed0b6ee/src/nimblepkg/tools.nim(11, 23) Error: cannot open file: /usr/lib/nim/compiler/nimblecmd
       Tip: 30 messages have been suppressed, use --verbose to show them.
nimble.nim(229)          buildFromDir

    Error:  Build failed for the package: nimble

[SpotlightKid]

Building nimble/nimble using c backend
/tmp/nimble_4649/githubcom_nimlangnimble_#ed0b6ee/src/nimblepkg/tools.nim(11, 23) Error: cannot open file: /usr/lib/nim/compiler/nimblecmd
       Tip: 30 messages have been suppressed, use --verbose to show them.
nimble.nim(229)          buildFromDir

This is a problem with your alpine Nim installation. It is missing the compiler package. This can happen, for example, if you use the install.sh script from the Nim source distribution to install Nim to /usr, instead of running Nim from the build directory or installing it to another prefix. This unfortunately also affects many Linux distribution packages for Nim.

You can use the nimlang/nim:alpine docker image (not official) to build choosenim. It has nim (currently 2.0.8) installed to the /nim prefix:

$ wget https://github.com/nim-lang/choosenim/archive/refs/tags/v0.8.9.tar.gz
$ docker run --rm -v `pwd`:/usr/src/app -w /usr/src/app -it --init nimlang/nim:alpine /bin/sh
# tar -xzf v0.8.9.tar.gz
# cd choosenim-0.8.9
# nimble install
  Verifying dependencies for choosenim@0.8.9
Downloading Official package list
    Success Package list downloaded.
 Installing https://github.com/nim-lang/sat@any version
Downloading https://github.com/nim-lang/sat using git
   Warning: The package has no tagged releases, downloading HEAD instead.
  Verifying dependencies for sat@0.1.0
 Installing sat@0.1.0
  Success:  sat installed successfully.
 Installing nimble@#ed0b6ee
Downloading https://github.com/nim-lang/nimble using git
   Warning: Package 'nimble' has an incorrect structure. It should contain a single directory hierarchy for source files, named 'nimble', but file 'options.nim' is in a directory named 'nimblepkg' instead. This will be an error in the future.
      Hint: If 'nimblepkg' contains source files for building 'nimble', rename it to 'nimble'. Otherwise, prevent its installation by adding `skipDirs = @["nimblepkg"]` to the .nimble file.
  Verifying dependencies for nimble@0.14.2
     Info:  Dependency on sat@any version already satisfied
  Verifying dependencies for sat@0.1.0
 Installing checksums@any version
Downloading https://github.com/nim-lang/checksums using git
  Verifying dependencies for checksums@0.2.1
 Installing checksums@0.2.1
  Success:  checksums installed successfully.
 Installing nimble@0.14.2
   Building nimble/nimble using c backend
  Success:  nimble installed successfully.
 Installing libcurl@>= 1.0.0
Downloading https://github.com/Araq/libcurl using git
  Verifying dependencies for libcurl@1.0.0
 Installing libcurl@1.0.0
  Success:  libcurl installed successfully.
 Installing osinfo@any version
Downloading https://github.com/nim-lang/osinfo.git using git
  Verifying dependencies for osinfo@0.3.2
 Installing osinfo@0.3.2
  Success:  osinfo installed successfully.
 Installing zippy@>= 0.7.2
Downloading https://github.com/guzba/zippy using git
  Verifying dependencies for zippy@0.10.16
 Installing zippy@0.10.16
  Success:  zippy installed successfully.
 Installing choosenim@0.8.9
   Building choosenim/choosenim using c backend
/root/.nimble/pkgs2/nimble-0.14.2-d7a5be15af06f993ee52303b8797d56a4caa7c3b/nimblepkg/options.nim(270, 16) Warning: Couldn't determine GIT hash: fatal: not a git repository (or any of the parent directories): .git [User]
/usr/src/app/choosenim-0.8.9/src/choosenimpkg/download.nim(73, 26) Warning: See corresponding Defect; AssertionError is deprecated [Deprecated]
/usr/src/app/choosenim-0.8.9/src/choosenimpkg/switcher.nim(9, 10) Warning: imported and not used: 'utils' [UnusedImport]
  Success:  choosenim installed successfully.
# choosenim stable
Downloading Nim 2.2.0 from nim-lang.org
[##################################################] 100.0% 0kb/s
 Extracting nim-2.2.0-linux_x64.tar.xz
 Extracting nim-2.2.0-linux_x64.tar
   Building Nim 2.2.0
  Compiler: Already built
  Installed component 'nim'
    Removed symlink pointing to ../pkgs2/nimble-0.14.2-d7a5be15af06f993ee52303b8797d56a4caa7c3b/nimble
  Installed component 'nimble'
  Installed component 'nimgrep'
  Installed component 'nimpretty'
  Installed component 'nimsuggest'
  Installed component 'testament'
  Installed component 'nim-gdb'
   Switched to Nim 2.2.0
# nim -v
Nim Compiler Version 2.2.0 [Linux: amd64]
Compiled at 2024-10-02
Copyright (c) 2006-2024 by Andreas Rumpf

git hash: 78983f1876726a49c69d65629ab433ea1310ece1
active boot switches: -d:release

[ITwrx]

This is a problem with your alpine Nim installation. It is missing the compiler package. This can happen, for example, if you use the install.sh script from the Nim source distribution to install Nim to /usr, instead of running Nim from the build directory or installing it to another prefix. This unfortunately also affects many Linux distribution packages for Nim.

I don't understand. What is wrong with Nim distro packages? I'm looking to update the Alpine Nim package. Is there something i should be correcting?

You can use the nimlang/nim:alpine docker image (not official) to build choosenim. It has nim (currently 2.0.8) installed to the /nim prefix:

Thanks for the workaround, but it didn't work for me. Don't remember why. I don't use Docker, so maybe i was doing something wrong. It's OK, but i'm curious why the docker image would install to /nim and/or why that would be a good thing.

[ITwrx]

well, i forked the nim package in the alpine gitlab and updated it and installed nim 2.2.0 successfully, but the nimble package failed to build. When investigating that, i see that araq says nimble should not be in a separate package, but that one could install nimble with koch nimble --latest. but koch was not installed by the/my alpine package, it seems. I think i'm done with this for today...

[SpotlightKid]

koch is a tool that is part of the Nim source distribution and not meant to be installed. It is used to build the nim tools (nimble, nimsuggest, etc.) after the nim compiler itself has been build. Then these tools will be installed by the install script alongside the nim executable. So they should be part of a binary nim distribution package. But not koch. And nimble should not be installed from a nimble package.

[ITwrx]

ok, so my Nim alpine package should have used koch temporarily to build nimble when it was doing the other stuff.

thanks

[SpotlightKid]

correct