RFC: withForms

[gjanvier]

Which @ngrx/* package(s) are relevant/related to the feature request?

signals

Information

Hello there,

I find signalStore great and use it on my professional projets. One of my very common use-case is to handle a list of items in my store, and handle a SearchComponent that simply filter what is displayed in my MainComponent.

My favorite pattern regarding such form is:

• The use of Reactive Forms
• That form should belong to the Store
• Any Search Component (or its sub-component) should inject that Store so that it can get access to its formControl
• The current state of that form should easily be read / computed using Signals

For this purpose, I created a utility function withForms() that solves my concerns in a few lines.

const MyStore = signalStore(
  withState({ items: [] }),

  // Adds search, searchValue and searchChanges to our Store
  withForms(() => ({ search: makeMySearchForm() })),

  withComputed(({ items, searchValue }) => ({
    filteredItems: computed(() => {
      const text = searchValue();
      return items().filter((item) => item.includes(text));
    }),
  }))
);

Here is a demo: https://stackblitz.com/edit/stackblitz-starters-6gqjsgtc?file=src%2Fmain.ts

The code for withForms() is quite simple but very convenient. Yet I don't know if it is worth being part of ngrx/signals? ;-)

Features:

• adds 1 or many Form (FormControl, FormGroup) to the Store props
• adds 1 or many Signals (pattern is: ${nameOfTheForm}Value, with the appropriate type hints
• adds 1 or many Observable for form changes (pattern is: ${nameOfTheForm}Changes) with type hints
• support debounceTime to avoid too many updates

Describe any alternatives/workarounds you're currently using

I used to keep the SearchComponent being responsible for instanciating such ReactiveForms and then updating my SignalStore with a "set" method, using an Observable, an Effect, etc.

Yet, bringing that Form into the SignalStore is so convenient, and so is a utility to transform that form into a Signal...

I would be willing to submit a PR to fix this issue

• Yes
• No

[markostanimirovic]

Since the Angular team plans to introduce new (signal) form APIs in the upcoming versions, this feature will become obsolete relatively soon if it is implemented with existing Angular form APIs (FormGroup, FormControl, etc.).

Therefore, we will put this feature request on hold. We will revisit it when Angular publishes new signal forms.