-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 2.1k
Potential bugs in /relations
endpoint #13862
Description
The /relations
endpoint is similar to /messages
, but essentially filters over a subset of events related to a specific event.
The core code that figures out which events to return from /relations
is synapse.handlers.relations.RelationsHandler.get_relations
, while for /messages
it is synapse.handlers.pagination.PaginationHandler.get_messages
, these then call down into similar datastore methods.
There's some subtle (and not so subtle) differences between them.
Differences which might cause bugs:
- I think both start at the "current" stream token if no
from_token
is given, butget_messages
calculates this, whileget_relations
leaves it implicit and just searches to the edge of the table. get_messages
takes a "pagination" lock -- should this be shared withget_relations
?get_messages
tries harder to not show users things from when they were not in the room.get_messages
might backfill.get_messages
fetches 2 * limit and then filters with_filter_results
which is something to do with a multi-worker setup.get_relations
does not do this.
Interface differenes (I don't think these are bugs, but are just confusing when trying to compare the two methods):
get_messages
always returns a "next"StreamToken
and then sometimes doesn't use it;get_relations
does not return one when there's no more data.- Not really a bug, but this means that
get_messages
will sometimes return a stream token when there's no additional data, e.g. if the last page has exactlylimit
entries in it. This will (potentially) cause an extra roundtrip from the client which could easily be avoided in most cases.
- Not really a bug, but this means that
from_token
is optional inget_relations
(see first bullet point above -- I suspect this logic of finding the proper starting point should be shared).- Both implementations have a bunch of shared code (e.g. figuring out the from and to boundaries, calling
generate_pagination_where_clause
, generating the "next" token).
The final bit of this is that we likely don't test this endpoint as thoroughly as /messages
. There's a start to some integration tests at matrix-org/complement#467, but they're very simplistic.