Invites need to convey a better summary of the room they describe.

[ara4n]

Currently we allow a subset of state events through in an invite.

This isn't enough to correctly calculate the name & avatar of a room based on matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals#688.

Either we need to somehow include enough state in the invite (e.g. a hypothetical m.room.summary event, plus a bunch of m.room.members for the heroes), or we need to change things so that invitees can peek into the live DAG of an invited room and draw their own conclusions.

If we supported invitees peeking into the live DAG of an invited room this would also solve things like the problems around supporting encryption for invited users before they join a room - c.f. element-hq/element-web#2713 (comment)

[bwindels]

An alternative could be that the server includes a room summary under the same conditions as for joined rooms (no name or avatar set...), and if the summary needs to have heroes, augment the invite_state with the member events for the heroes.

Allowing invitees to have access to the DAG might be useful, but I think we'd still need a room summary, because you wouldn't want to have to load all the members to give an accurate name and avatar for a room you got invited to.

[ara4n]

An alternative could be that the server includes a room summary under the same conditions as for joined rooms (no name or avatar set...), and if the summary needs to have heroes, augment the invite_state with the member events for the heroes.

Yup, this is what i was trying to suggest in the first option in the original comment:

Either we need to somehow include enough state in the invite (e.g. a hypothetical m.room.summary event, plus a bunch of m.room.members for the heroes)

[ara4n]

If we were allowing direct access to the DAG, then we'd get the room summary for free, i think, as it'd probably look like a joined room, so the same rules would apply for calculating the /sync details for it.

[KitsuneRal]

This is solved by MSC3266, isn't it?

[richvdh]

I'd have thought so. It seems to have bitrotted, in any case.