-dtd option

[y2kenny]

When I try to parse a dtd (using sourceType dtd), I get the following error

org.xml.sax.SAXParseException: Are you trying to compile DTD? Support for DTD is experimental. You may enable it by using the -dtd option.

How do I pass the -dtd option to xjc via this plugin?

[stephan-vollmer]

I'm having the same issue (plugin version 0.15.1 with Java 11.0.16).

I tried to specify the -dtd argument, but the warning still appears:

<configuration>
    <generatePackage>...</generatePackage>
    <generateDirectory>${project.build.directory}/generated-sources/xjc1</generateDirectory>
    <schemaIncludes>
        <schemaInclude>filename.dtd</schemaInclude>
    </schemaIncludes>
    <markGenerated>true</markGenerated>
    <args>
        <arg>-dtd</arg>
    </args>
</configuration>

[gigermocas]

you have a schemaLanguage configuration option:

<schemaLanguage>dtd</schemaLanguage>

[y2kenny]

you have a schemaLanguage configuration option:

<schemaLanguage>dtd</schemaLanguage>

I have that but it did not remove the error.

[dkowis]

I have both dtd and tried the args bit, unfortunately it's not working.

[mattrpav]

There is a newer dtd dependency out there. I'm cutting a 0.15.2 first to try to clear up more critical issues than this WARN msg

[laurentschoelens]

@y2kenny / @stephan-vollmer : could you please provide an example file to test your issue ? Thanks

[y2kenny]

@y2kenny / @stephan-vollmer : could you please provide an example file to test your issue ? Thanks

This is the dtd file I have used before:
https://gerrit.googlesource.com/plugins/manifest-subscription/+/refs/heads/master/src/main/resources/schemas/manifest.dtd

[laurentschoelens]

Thanks for the quick reply, will look at this issue soon 😉

[laurentschoelens]

@y2kenny : found the culprit
A change has been made (maybe a typo in earlier version of xjc), that made schemaLanguage != XMLSCHEMA complains about DTD / WSDL generating code since it's "experimental".
See : eclipse-ee4j/jaxb-ri@94a5a1f

There's nothing (in my opinion) we can do to get rid of this message (it's just a warning for 'experimental' features that still exists in v4 of xjc, with more generation warning about rng / rnc files) and your classes are just generated fine (tested against current 2.0.3-SNAPSHOT).
@mattrpav : do you agree with me ?

[laurentschoelens]

Found this issue in jaxb-ri impl that was treated in main : eclipse-ee4j/jaxb-ri#1701
Asked if any backport for 2.3.x branch will be done.

[laurentschoelens]

@y2kenny : this should be fixed in 4.0.4 based-jaxb-tools and 2.3.9 based jaxb-tools since Lukas is doing some backports in EE8 branch of JAXB-RI
We should be able to test and validate it with jaxb-tools 2.X branch and then release a fixed version based on latest jaxb-ri

[laurentschoelens]

@y2kenny / @stephan-vollmer / @dkowis / @gigermocas : sorry for the spam 😄 This was fixed in v4.0.2 of jaxb-tools

This will also be fixed in v2.0.10