Add support for scroll position sync #2404
Conversation
|
You can see the demonstration ↓ 2024-09-03-markdown-scroll-sync.mp4 |
guanglinn
changed the title
|
has conflicts |
|
Conflicts are resolved :) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Tried locally,
unfortunately not works quite well for both directions. From View-Mode to Edit-Mode it seems to works good enough.
But from Edit to View mode it seems to not work, always jumps to top of document.
This is the builtin Markdown reference.
screenrecord-2024-09-25_00.59.29.webm
|
I've merged your other PR to master as well, made conflicts again |
|
Conflicts are resolved now. |
|
Sure, from Edit to View, it works well for quite a lot common text blocks such as Headings, Bold, Italic, Blockquotes, Lists, Links, ... , but it works not quite well for some special text blocks. I have tried to solve this, it's quite difficult, and I think this could be a big progress for Markor can provide a rough position synch for Markdown. You can merge it first, it's stable now, and I will improve it if I have some better solutions later. |
|
What I would suggest for now: Save/Restore last webview scroll position after short delay (when blocks have the right rendered size). As far I recall this has been before like that, but somehow it doesn't work currently on master either |
|
Can an option be added? Allow users to choose to let Markor restore last WebView scroll position, or sync WebView scroll position from Edit. |
|
I don't think it's neccassary. When scroll sync work good enough in praxis there is also the editor position saved/restored - so will be view-mode position when switiching to. |
|
Unfortunatley also keep in mind what I tried to say always - Markor is not only Markdown. This all relies on Markdown specific injections/adjusting the original. This won't work for stuff that doesn't base on Markdown converter. So we need in any case such a fallback. And saving/restoring the view-mode scroll position should be viable for that. It can't be resolved generically for everything and not easy to get much stable. |
|
Improvements: If we want to go back to the last view position, just long click the toolbar. |
|
@harshad1 @wshoy @elyahw I watched guanglinns video again, but it just not works as good here at least in one way, which overall seems also worse then without the PR. In such case I don't feel too well either with bearing that by default to users. Also very important to me: it's a feature for Markdown. People will rumble because not available/broken for others, issues inevitable. |
|
This feature feels great on an emulator, but unfortunately, it mostly doesn't work on my phone. On an emulator, when going from view mode to edit mode, it often jumps to the next line. Probably because of the word wrapping. |
| showSelection(text, text.getSelectionStart(), text.getSelectionEnd()); | ||
| } | ||
|
|
||
| public static void setSelectionAndShow(final EditText edit, boolean setSelection, final int... sel) { |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
We have showSelection to show the selection and setSelectionAndShow to set selection and show. Having a boolean flag here to setSelection in a function called setSelectionAndShow is poor design imo. Just call the right function
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Okay, I have made some improvements for this.
| } | ||
| } | ||
|
|
||
| public static void setSelectionAndShow(final EditText edit, final int... sel) { |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Separate functions are better than flags unless there is a good reason.
|
PR has many conflicts (and some open discussionsI, converting it to draft for now. Thanks! |
Thanks, |
|
No problem and understandable. I also have quite little time available recently, and have to take care of my physical health. |
|
Yes, time and physical health are the most precious. |
4 participants
Add basic support for scroll position sync between Markdown preview (view-mode) and its source code (edit-mode).
This feature supports:
The related issues:
#2373 #2189 #1070 #1060 #679.