[FEATURE] Support LSP4IJ to be available on all IntelliJ-based IDEs

[antruongnguyen]

Description

Currently, the plugin is only available for the paid versions of IntelliJ IDEs. The reason is that the plugin uses the LSP API, which is only available in commercial IntelliJ IDEs. This is why the plugin does not work with the free variants (such as IntelliJ Community).

LSP4IJ is a free and open-source Language Server Protocol (LSP) client compatible with all flavors of IntelliJ. The LSP4IJ plugin is available here, and its source code is located here.

Suggested Solution

Please support LSP4IJ in order to replace IntelliJ LSP API

Source code: https://github.com/redhat-developer/lsp4ij

Alternatives

No response

Additional Context

No response

[manwithafox]

@antruongnguyen Thank you for this hint. Actually in the past we had an (SAP internal) IJ plugin based on another LSP client lib. But that had a pretty clumsy integration. Far away from production quality.

The current approach gives us more trust as IJ itself provides the client side integration. Though, as you spotted, they do not support community editions, AND, while continuously improving, still lack many feature.

Taking a look into the source of LSP4IJ shows that they already have very broad request support and they are pacing fast - just a year since initial release.

I did a short manual configuration to try it out:

In Settings->Languages&Frameworks->Language Servers I created a new entry CDS with command node /path/to/@sap/cds-lsp/dist/main.js --stdio.
In the Mappings tab added an entry for file pattern *.cds with lang id cds, left Configuration tab empty.
Et voilà. It works already pretty nicely. Though there are some quirks we need to investigate.

E.g.

• Alt-F7 Find Usages is not supported, but a proprietary GoTo->LSP references with special dialog.
• Command-Hover highlights the wrong scope.
• ... to be extended

[angelozerr]

Alt-F7 Find Usages is not supported, but a proprietary GoTo->LSP references with special dialog.

@antruongnguyen please note that LSP4IJ have a luck to have the contributor @SCWells72 which is working hard to have standard IDE actions like redhat-developer/lsp4ij#637

Command-Hover highlights the wrong scope.

Could you create an issue with a detailed info please.

... to be extended

Don'thesitate to create any issues.

[angelozerr]

@antruongnguyen Thank you for this hint. Actually in the past we had an (SAP internal) IJ plugin based on another LSP client lib. But that had a pretty clumsy integration. Far away from production quality.

The current approach gives us more trust as IJ itself provides the client side integration. Though, as you spotted, they do not support community editions, AND, while continuously improving, still lack many feature.

Taking a look into the source of LSP4IJ shows that they already have very broad request support and they are pacing fast - just a year since initial release.

I did a short manual configuration to try it out:

Please note that you can import / export the configuration that you have explained below. See https://github.com/redhat-developer/lsp4ij/blob/main/docs/UserDefinedLanguageServer.md#custom-template

In Settings->Languages&Frameworks->Language Servers I created a new entry CDS with command node /path/to/@sap/cds-lsp/dist/main.js --stdio.
In the Mappings tab added an entry for file pattern *.cds with lang id cds, left Configuration tab empty.
Et voilà. It works already pretty nicely. Though there are some quirks we need to investigate.

E.g.

• Alt-F7 Find Usages is not supported, but a proprietary GoTo->LSP references with special dialog.
• Command-Hover highlights the wrong scope.
• ... to be extended

[rjayasinghe]

It would be pretty neat (especially cost-wise) if we had this plugin available for IntelliJ CE, too. The CDS support is actually the main reason why I got the paid Ultimate version.

[manwithafox]

Just a short notice: I'm currently working on this... : )

[angelozerr]

@manwithafox I have noticed that you are using now LSP4IJ, it is fantastic!

Could you please create a PR to LSP4IJ to add it to
https://github.com/redhat-developer/lsp4ij?tab=readme-ov-file#who-is-using-lsp4ij please

And if you like LSP4IJ could you please add a review https://plugins.jetbrains.com/plugin/23257-lsp4ij/reviews to help us to promote LSP4IJ

Thanks!

[manwithafox]

@manwithafox I have noticed that you are using now LSP4IJ, it is fantastic!

Could you please create a PR to LSP4IJ to add it to redhat-developer/lsp4ij#who-is-using-lsp4ij please

And if you like LSP4IJ could you please add a review plugins.jetbrains.com/plugin/23257-lsp4ij/reviews to help us to promote LSP4IJ

Thanks!

Once we release this to the Marketplace I will create the PR. Thanks