Skip to content

OrthotropicSolid seems to be wrong #680

@WeiyiVirtonomy

Description

@WeiyiVirtonomy

The function CalculateAllLambda() defines the compliance matrix as:

    Matd Compliance = Matd::Zero();
    Compliance.col(0) = Vecd(1 / E_[0], -poisson_[0] / E_[1], -poisson_[1] / E_[2]);
    Compliance.col(1) = Vecd(-poisson_[0] / E_[0], 1 / E_[1], -poisson_[2] / E_[1]);
    Compliance.col(2) = Vecd(-poisson_[1] / E_[0], -poisson_[2] / E_[1], 1 / E_[2]);

Shouldn't it be

    Matd Compliance = Matd::Zero();
    Compliance.col(0) = Vecd(1 / E_[0], -poisson_[0] / E_[0], -poisson_[1] / E_[0]);
    Compliance.col(1) = Vecd(-poisson_[0] / E_[0], 1 / E_[1], -poisson_[2] / E_[1]);
    Compliance.col(2) = Vecd(-poisson_[1] / E_[0], -poisson_[2] / E_[1], 1 / E_[2]);

?

The definition of mu also has problems. It should be:

Mu_[0] = G_[0] + G_[2] - G_[1];
Mu_[1] = G_[1] + G_[0] - G_[2];
Mu_[2] = G_[2] + G_[1] - G_[0];

The sound speed cannot be defined by E_max and nu_max, as the material parameter relation derived from isotropic material no longer holds for the orthotropic case. I think we can replace it by lambda_max + 2/3*G_max.

The result of the test case is still weird after making those corrections. I'll also check the implementation of PK2 stress

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions