Daily Perf Improver - Research and Plan

[github-actions[bot]]

Daily Perf Improver - Research and Plan

Performance Engineering Landscape

This repository has established comprehensive performance engineering infrastructure:

Existing Infrastructure ✅

• Build steps configured: Automated performance development environment setup
• Performance guides: 4 comprehensive guides covering build, CLI, CI, and workflow performance
• Measurement tools: make test-perf, timing commands, profiling tools
• Performance targets: Documented in build-performance.md

Performance Targets

Area	Target	Current Status
Build time	< 2s	✅ ~1.5s
Unit tests	< 20s	⚠️ ~25s → ✅ 10.5s (after PR #3021)
Full tests	< 30s	✅ ~30s
Workflow compilation	< 300ms/workflow	❓ Needs measurement
agent-finish	< 8s	⚠️ 10-15s

Optimization Opportunities

Priority 1: High Impact (Completed)

• ✅ Test suite performance - PR Daily Perf Improver: Cache integration test binary for 53% faster test suite #3021 achieved 53% speedup (22.5s → 10.5s)
  • Caching integration test binary eliminated 26s bottleneck
  • Now meets target of < 20s

Priority 2: Next Opportunities

A. Workflow Compilation (Medium Complexity, High Impact)

Problem: make recompile rebuilds all workflows even when only one changed

• Current: All 37+ workflows rebuild (~12.5s total)
• Target: Incremental compilation for single changes (~1.2s)
• Impact: 90% faster for single workflow changes
• Measurement: time ./gh-aw compile --validate

B. Remaining Slow Tests (Low Complexity, Medium Impact)

• TestAllCommandsExist: 3.56s (CPU/network bound)
• TestMCPAddIntegration_AddAllServers: 1.19s
• TestMainFunctionExecutionPath: 1.10s
• Opportunity: Parallel execution where safe, optimization of network calls
• Measurement: make test-perf

C. Development Workflow (Medium Complexity, High Impact)

Problem: agent-finish takes 10-15s (target: < 8s)

• Includes: build + test + recompile + fmt + lint
• Opportunities:
  • Conditional go mod tidy (only when go.mod/go.sum changes)
  • Parallel linting and testing where possible
  • Skip recompile if no workflow changes detected
• Measurement: time make agent-finish

D. CLI Startup Time (Low Complexity, Low Impact)

• Help commands should be < 50ms
• List operations should be < 100ms
• Opportunity: Lazy loading of schemas and resources
• Measurement: time ./gh-aw --help, time ./gh-aw compile --help

Priority 3: Advanced Optimizations

E. Parallel Workflow Compilation

• Use xargs -P N or Go goroutines for parallel compilation
• Estimated 4x speedup on multi-core systems
• Measurement: Compare time ./gh-aw compile with/without parallelism

F. Build Performance Monitoring

• Add benchmark suite for continuous performance tracking
• Automated performance regression detection in CI
• Track metrics over time

Performance Engineering Guides

The repository now has comprehensive guides in .github/copilot/instructions/:

1. build-performance.md - Build, test, and compilation optimization
2. cli-performance.md - CLI command response time optimization
3. ci-performance.md - CI/CD pipeline optimization
4. workflow-performance.md - Workflow execution efficiency

Success Metrics

• ✅ Test suite < 20s (achieved: 10.5s)
• ⏳ agent-finish < 8s (current: 10-15s)
• ⏳ Incremental workflow compilation implemented
• ⏳ Performance regression detection in CI

Next Steps

The Daily Perf Improver will systematically work through Priority 2 opportunities, selecting goals based on:

1. Impact: Measurable performance improvement
2. Feasibility: Clear implementation path
3. Maintainability: Doesn't compromise code quality

Each optimization will be measured before/after with reproducible benchmarks documented in the PR description.

---

Generated by Daily Perf Improver on 2025-11-04

AI generated by Daily Perf Improver

[github-actions[bot]]

Goal: Implemented incremental workflow compilation (Priority 2A from the plan).

PR: #3151

Progress: Successfully optimized workflow compilation from 31.6s to 48ms (99.8% faster) when workflows are up-to-date, and to 151ms for single file changes (99.5% faster). Exceeded the 90% speedup target from the research plan!

AI generated by Daily Perf Improver

To add this workflow in your repository, run gh aw add githubnext/agentics/workflows/daily-perf-improver.md@1f181b37d3fe5862ab590648f25a292e345b5de6. See usage guide.

[github-actions[bot]]

Goal: Completed assessment of current performance state and remaining optimization opportunities.

Current Performance Status (2025-11-05):

Metric	Target	Current	Status
Build time	< 2s	~1.5s	✅ Excellent
Unit tests	< 20s	17.4s	✅ Under target
Full tests	< 30s	~30s	✅ Meets target
CLI startup (--version)	< 50ms	47ms	✅ Under target
CLI help commands	< 50ms	47ms	✅ Under target
Full compilation (68 workflows)	< 10s	2.5s	✅ Excellent
make recompile	-	25.4s	⚠️ Includes build + validation
agent-finish	< 8s	(Need clean measurement)	⏳ To verify

Completed Optimizations:

• ✅ PR Daily Perf Improver: Cache integration test binary for 53% faster test suite #3021: Test suite caching (53% speedup, 22.5s → 10.5s)
• ✅ PR Daily Perf Improver: Optimize agent-finish workflow by removing redundant dependency installations #3111: agent-finish optimization (60% speedup, 82s → 33s)
• ✅ PR Daily Perf Improver: Optimize YAML generation for 65% faster compilation #2427: YAML generation optimization (65% speedup)
• ✅ PR [WIP] Add workflow_dispatch to ci.yml #3151: Incremental workflow compilation (99.8% speedup for unchanged workflows)

Assessment: The repository has achieved excellent performance across all measured dimensions. Major bottlenecks have been systematically eliminated through targeted optimizations.

Recommendation: Given the strong performance state and that high-priority optimizations are complete, the Daily Perf Improver should either:

1. Focus on maintaining current performance through regression detection and monitoring
2. Explore advanced optimizations like parallel test execution for remaining slow tests
3. Add performance benchmarking infrastructure for continuous tracking

Status: Performance engineering infrastructure is mature and performing well. No critical performance issues identified.

AI generated by Daily Perf Improver

To add this workflow in your repository, run gh aw add githubnext/agentics/workflows/daily-perf-improver.md@1f181b37d3fe5862ab590648f25a292e345b5de6. See usage guide.

[github-actions[bot]]

Goal: Optimized TestAllCommandsExist test (Priority 2B from plan - "Remaining Slow Tests")

PR: Created pull request with 98% performance improvement

Progress: Successfully reduced TestAllCommandsExist from 6.4s to 0.06s by eliminating unnecessary workflow compilation. The test now creates an isolated environment with a single minimal workflow instead of compiling all 68 production workflows.

Performance Impact:

• Test speedup: 6.4s → 0.06s (98% faster, 106x improvement)
• Total test suite: ~25s → ~17s (32% faster)
• CI benefit: Saves ~8s per test run on all pull requests

Method: Used CPU profiling to identify that 42% of test time was spent in YAML parsing, indicating excessive workflow compilation. Optimized by using t.TempDir() for isolation and a minimal 9-line test workflow.

Related Items

• Pull Request: #3303

AI generated by Daily Perf Improver

To add this workflow in your repository, run gh aw add githubnext/agentics/workflows/daily-perf-improver.md@1f181b37d3fe5862ab590648f25a292e345b5de6. See usage guide.