[OP Stack Deployment] Withdrawal of ERC20 token from L2

[tiagorvmartins]

Did you check the documentation?

• Yes

Did you check for duplicate questions?

• Yes

Issue Description

Hey! I am currently having some issues withdrawing an ERC20 token from L2 -> L1, where L2 is a local chain that I just spinned up using op-stack.

I was able to deploy the correspondant L2 ERC20 Token based on my L1 ERC20 Token using the OptimismMintableERC20Factory as per instructions mention in the docs.

Also was able to do a deposit of that same L1 ERC20 token using the L1StandardBridge currently deployed on sepolia.
But everytime I do try an withdraw from L2 (following the docs) I am getting:

withdrawal index 0 out of bounds. There are 0 withdrawals

Is this expected?
Below you can check more details about the contract details feeded into the CrossChainMessenger constructor,
I do know that @eth-optimism/sdk has been deprecated but viem (op-stack - https://github.com/wevm/viem/tree/main/src/op-stack) doesn't have yet support for bridging ERC20 as far as I am aware, right?

const messenger = new CrossChainMessenger({
        l1ChainId: 11155111, // 11155111 Sepolia
        l2ChainId: 71936, // My L2 chainId
        l1SignerOrProvider: l1Wallet,
        l2SignerOrProvider: l2Wallet,
        contracts: {
            l1: {
                AddressManager: "0xdDB333ee6C23CD5e446567B6dBC02511958B1D98",  
                L1CrossDomainMessenger: '0xd2003CdBC879d5b0b945D65464E8aB2451956654',  //L1CrossDomainMessengerProxy from contract deployment on L1
                L1StandardBridge: '0xA9e71E7921ba6568b9E6a7918CFCA4a01bf309c5',  //L1StandardBridgeProxy from contract deployment on L1
                StateCommitmentChain: ethers.constants.AddressZero,  //As found in other source code details
                CanonicalTransactionChain: ethers.constants.AddressZero, //As found in other source code details
                BondManager: ethers.constants.AddressZero, //As found in other source code details
                OptimismPortal: '0x782B67BaBd2Ac4E00eB455B8f03C5C0E26c1554b',  //OptimismPortalProxy from contract deployment on L1
                L2OutputOracle: '0x10E46dBa464E233f210D98c1cf5d601649447311',   //L2OutputOracleProxy from contract deployment on L1         
            },
        },
        bridges: {
            [71936]: {
                Adapter: SDBridgeAdapter,  // Custom BridgeAdapter that just extends StandardBridgeAdapter with supportsTokenPair returning always true
                    l1Bridge: '0xA9e71E7921ba6568b9E6a7918CFCA4a01bf309c5',  //L1StandardBridgeProxy from contract deployment on L1 
                    l2Bridge: '0x4200000000000000000000000000000000000010',  //Predeploy of L2StandardBridge contract in L2
                }
        },
    })

Any clues on how to proceed? Thank you!

Logs

No response

Additional Information

No response

Feedback

No response

[opfocus]

does your testnet chain support fault-poof, which step this error occured? you can step by step implement to debug steps in Node.js REPL
Start the Node.js REPL with the node command.
node

[tiagorvmartins]

Hey @opfocus thank you for your reply, it's not a fault-proof supported chain, it fails when submitting the withdrawal transaction to L2, below you can find the reproducible steps and the logs.

Here are the settings of the testnet chain I am currently using for this withdrawal test

{
  "l1StartingBlockTag": "0xdb9829c29376953c299a4a579efb2f0aa604725a2397d7fb6b1f2f00c36d532d",
  "l1ChainID": 11155111,
  "l2ChainID": 71936,
  "l2BlockTime": 2,
  "l1BlockTime": 12,
  "maxSequencerDrift": 600,
  "sequencerWindowSize": 3600,
  "channelTimeout": 300,
  "p2pSequencerAddress": "0x0b59BF2004bf203E6e73d60EF638D410469629BD",
  "batchInboxAddress": "0xff00000000000000000000000000000000071936",
  "batchSenderAddress": "0x916E2645cCeE24BA2bC867336e3A26001e57Fc13",
  "l2OutputOracleSubmissionInterval": 120,
  "l2OutputOracleStartingBlockNumber": 0,
  "l2OutputOracleStartingTimestamp": 1741102080,
  "l2OutputOracleProposer": "0x729a1f2fE583CdfADF0fc0D89efcA3c730bd9290",
  "l2OutputOracleChallenger": "0xd8085b571E2D4182704F19fB73a320a5657f7302",
  "finalizationPeriodSeconds": 12,
  "proxyAdminOwner": "0xd8085b571E2D4182704F19fB73a320a5657f7302",
  "baseFeeVaultRecipient": "0xd8085b571E2D4182704F19fB73a320a5657f7302",
  "l1FeeVaultRecipient": "0xd8085b571E2D4182704F19fB73a320a5657f7302",
  "sequencerFeeVaultRecipient": "0xd8085b571E2D4182704F19fB73a320a5657f7302",
  "finalSystemOwner": "0xd8085b571E2D4182704F19fB73a320a5657f7302",
  "superchainConfigGuardian": "0xd8085b571E2D4182704F19fB73a320a5657f7302",
  "baseFeeVaultMinimumWithdrawalAmount": "0x8ac7230489e80000",
  "l1FeeVaultMinimumWithdrawalAmount": "0x8ac7230489e80000",
  "sequencerFeeVaultMinimumWithdrawalAmount": "0x8ac7230489e80000",
  "baseFeeVaultWithdrawalNetwork": 0,
  "l1FeeVaultWithdrawalNetwork": 0,
  "sequencerFeeVaultWithdrawalNetwork": 0,
  "gasPriceOracleOverhead": 0,
  "gasPriceOracleScalar": 1000000,
  "enableGovernance": true,
  "governanceTokenSymbol": "OP",
  "governanceTokenName": "Optimism",
  "governanceTokenOwner": "0xd8085b571E2D4182704F19fB73a320a5657f7302",
  "l2GenesisBlockGasLimit": "0x1c9c380",
  "l2GenesisBlockBaseFeePerGas": "0x3b9aca00",
  "eip1559Denominator": 50,
  "eip1559DenominatorCanyon": 250,
  "eip1559Elasticity": 6,
  "l2GenesisFjordTimeOffset": "0x0",
  "l2GenesisRegolithTimeOffset": "0x0",
  "l2GenesisEcotoneTimeOffset": "0x0",
  "l2GenesisDeltaTimeOffset": "0x0",
  "l2GenesisCanyonTimeOffset": "0x0",
  "systemConfigStartBlock": 0,
  "requiredProtocolVersion": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
  "recommendedProtocolVersion": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
  "faultGameAbsolutePrestate": "0x03c7ae758795765c6664a5d39bf63841c71ff191e9189522bad8ebff5d4eca98",
  "faultGameMaxDepth": 44,
  "faultGameClockExtension": 0,
  "faultGameMaxClockDuration": 1200,
  "faultGameGenesisBlock": 0,
  "faultGameGenesisOutputRoot": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
  "faultGameSplitDepth": 14,
  "faultGameWithdrawalDelay": 600,
  "preimageOracleMinProposalSize": 1800000,
  "preimageOracleChallengePeriod": 300,
  "proofMaturityDelaySeconds": 12,
  "disputeGameFinalityDelaySeconds": 6,
  "respectedGameType": 254,
  "useFaultProofs": false,
  "useAltDA": true,
  "daCommitmentType": "KeccakCommitment",
  "daChallengeWindow": 16,
  "daResolveWindow": 16,
  "daBondSize": 1000000,
  "daResolverRefundPercentage": 0
}

And here is the current test scenario I am running for the withdrawal

import { AddressLike, CrossChainMessenger, MessageStatus, StandardBridgeAdapter } from '@eth-optimism/sdk'
import { predeploys } from '@eth-optimism/core-utils'
import { ethers } from 'ethers'

class CustomBridgeAdapter extends StandardBridgeAdapter {
  public async supportsTokenPair(
    l1Token: AddressLike,
    l2Token: AddressLike
  ): Promise<boolean> {    
    return true
  }
}

async function test() {

    const privateKey = "<private_key>"

    const l1Provider = new ethers.providers.StaticJsonRpcProvider("https://ethereum-sepolia-rpc.publicnode.com")
    const l2Provider = new ethers.providers.StaticJsonRpcProvider("http://localhost:8545")
    const l1Wallet = new ethers.Wallet(privateKey, l1Provider)
    const l2Wallet = new ethers.Wallet(privateKey, l2Provider)
    
    const l1Token = "0xaC91Dc559006b23BcF8b1617fE83177AD74C5200"
    const l2Token = "0xCB5ef4e9e72D0DA950b9fFab92bF73723364E42c"

    const erc20ABI = [{
        constant: true,
        inputs: [],
        name: "name",
        outputs: [{ name: "", type: "string" }],
        stateMutability: "view",
        type: "function"
      },
      {
        constant: true,
        inputs: [],
        name: "symbol",
        outputs: [{ name: "", type: "string" }],
        stateMutability: "view",
        type: "function"
      },
      { constant: true, inputs: [{ name: "_owner", type: "address" }], name: "balanceOf", outputs: [{ name: "balance", type: "uint256" }], type: "function" }, { inputs: [], name: "faucet", outputs: [], stateMutability: "nonpayable", type: "function" }]

    const l1ERC20 = new ethers.Contract(l1Token, erc20ABI, l1Wallet)
    console.log("L1 ERC20 Token Name: ", await l1ERC20.name())
    console.log("L1 ERC20 Token Symbol: ", await l1ERC20.symbol())
    console.log("L1 ERC20 Token Symbol: ", await l1ERC20.address)
    console.log("Wallet ("+l1Wallet.address+") L1 ERC20 Token Amount: ", (await l1ERC20.balanceOf(l1Wallet.address)).toString())


    const l2ERC20 = new ethers.Contract(l2Token, erc20ABI, l2Wallet)
    console.log("L2 ERC20 Token Name: ", await l2ERC20.name())
    console.log("L2 ERC20 Token Symbol: ", await l2ERC20.symbol())
    console.log("L2 ERC20 Token Symbol: ", await l2ERC20.address)
    console.log("Wallet ("+l2Wallet.address+") L2 ERC20 Token Amount: ", (await l2ERC20.balanceOf(l2Wallet.address)).toString())


    const oneToken = 1000000000000000000n
    console.log('Withdrawing the L1 Token Amount: ', oneToken)    

    const messenger = new CrossChainMessenger({
        l1ChainId: 11155111, 
        l2ChainId: 71936,
        l1SignerOrProvider: l1Wallet,
        l2SignerOrProvider: l2Wallet,
        contracts: {
            l1: {
                AddressManager: "0xdDB333ee6C23CD5e446567B6dBC02511958B1D98",
                L1CrossDomainMessenger: '0xd2003CdBC879d5b0b945D65464E8aB2451956654',
                L1StandardBridge: '0xA9e71E7921ba6568b9E6a7918CFCA4a01bf309c5',
                StateCommitmentChain: ethers.constants.AddressZero,
                CanonicalTransactionChain: ethers.constants.AddressZero,
                BondManager: ethers.constants.AddressZero,
                OptimismPortal: '0x782B67BaBd2Ac4E00eB455B8f03C5C0E26c1554b',
                L2OutputOracle: '0x10E46dBa464E233f210D98c1cf5d601649447311',                
            },
            
        },
        bridges: {
            [71936]: {
                Adapter: CustomBridgeAdapter,
                    l1Bridge: '0xA9e71E7921ba6568b9E6a7918CFCA4a01bf309c5',
                    l2Bridge: '0x4200000000000000000000000000000000000010',
                }
        },
        
    })

    console.time('Withdrawing')
    const withdrawal = await messenger.withdrawERC20(l1Token, l2Token, oneToken, { 
        overrides: {
            gasLimit: 100_000n,
        }
    })  // fails submitting the transaction, logs below

    await withdrawal.wait()
        
    console.log('Balance on L2 after withdrawal')
    console.log("L2 ERC20 Token Name: ", await l2ERC20.name())
    console.log("L2 ERC20 Token Symbol: ", await l2ERC20.symbol())
    console.log("L2 ERC20 Token Symbol: ", await l2ERC20.address)

    console.log('Waiting for withdrawal to be ready to prove..')
    await messenger.waitForMessageStatus(withdrawal.hash, MessageStatus.READY_TO_PROVE)
    console.log('Withdrawal is ready to prove..')

   // ... more stuff as docs show but unrelevant for now
}

test()

Below you can see the logs of this execution:

L1 ERC20 Token Name:  TestTokenSD
L1 ERC20 Token Symbol:  TTSD
L1 ERC20 Token Symbol:  0xaC91Dc559006b23BcF8b1617fE83177AD74C5200
Wallet (0xea048Dca261968abD942Ec9583dbb83b8ACF614E) L1 ERC20 Token Amount:  999999999999999999999998000000000000000000


L2 ERC20 Token Name:  TestTokenSDL2
L2 ERC20 Token Symbol:  TTSDL2
L2 ERC20 Token Symbol:  0xCB5ef4e9e72D0DA950b9fFab92bF73723364E42c
Wallet (0xea048Dca261968abD942Ec9583dbb83b8ACF614E) L2 ERC20 Token Amount:  2000000000000000000


Withdrawing the L1 Token Amount:  1000000000000000000n
/project/node_modules/@ethersproject/logger/src.ts/index.ts:269
        const error: any = new Error(message);
                           ^


Error: transaction failed [ See: https://links.ethers.org/v5-errors-CALL_EXCEPTION ] (transactionHash="0x9e4c32a857ae09a59ea6368f9a49601b6202345d66a70fdd841fde1b307aa307", transaction={"type":2,"chainId":71936,"nonce":26,"maxPriorityFeePerGas":{"type":"BigNumber","hex":"0x59682f00"},"maxFeePerGas":{"type":"BigNumber","hex":"0x596830f8"},"gasPrice":null,"gasLimit":{"type":"BigNumber","hex":"0x0186a0"},"to":"0x4200000000000000000000000000000000000010","value":{"type":"BigNumber","hex":"0x00"},"data":"0x32b7006d000000000000000000000000cb5ef4e9e72d0da950b9ffab92bf73723364e42c0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000de0b6b3a7640000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000800000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","accessList":[],"hash":"0x9e4c32a857ae09a59ea6368f9a49601b6202345d66a70fdd841fde1b307aa307","v":0,"r":"0x1a975ad488a53931601b05ea90f993df8130152ce425b56f3babaaa2a42476f5","s":"0x3d914837c3b9dee470cf3a077c08520d8c4697072e1cdc728ecd112afed7a2bf","from":"0xea048Dca261968abD942Ec9583dbb83b8ACF614E","confirmations":0}, receipt={"to":"0x4200000000000000000000000000000000000010","from":"0xea048Dca261968abD942Ec9583dbb83b8ACF614E","contractAddress":null,"transactionIndex":1,"gasUsed":{"type":"BigNumber","hex":"0xa285"},"logsBloom":"0x00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","blockHash":"0x0a88a79996ebef640d35500b039b0acac541be6481fcfb4d77e8d213c9aefe0f","transactionHash":"0x9e4c32a857ae09a59ea6368f9a49601b6202345d66a70fdd841fde1b307aa307","logs":[],"blockNumber":86090,"confirmations":1,"cumulativeGasUsed":{"type":"BigNumber","hex":"0x014daf"},"effectiveGasPrice":{"type":"BigNumber","hex":"0x59682ffc"},"status":0,"type":2,"byzantium":true}, code=CALL_EXCEPTION, version=providers/5.8.0)
    at Logger.Logger.makeError (/project/node_modules/@ethersproject/logger/src.ts/index.ts:269:28)
    at Logger.Logger.throwError (/project/node_modules/@ethersproject/logger/src.ts/index.ts:281:20)
    at StaticJsonRpcProvider.<anonymous> (/project/node_modules/@ethersproject/providers/src.ts/base-provider.ts:1549:24)
    at step (/project/node_modules/@ethersproject/providers/src.ts/base-provider.ts:1:14)
    at Object.next (/project/node_modules/@ethersproject/providers/src.ts/base-provider.ts:1:14)
    at fulfilled (/project/node_modules/@ethersproject/providers/src.ts/base-provider.ts:1:14) {
  reason: 'transaction failed',
  code: 'CALL_EXCEPTION',
  transactionHash: '0x9e4c32a857ae09a59ea6368f9a49601b6202345d66a70fdd841fde1b307aa307',
  transaction: {
    type: 2,
    chainId: 71936,
    nonce: 26,
    maxPriorityFeePerGas: BigNumber { _hex: '0x59682f00', _isBigNumber: true },
    maxFeePerGas: BigNumber { _hex: '0x596830f8', _isBigNumber: true },
    gasPrice: null,
    gasLimit: BigNumber { _hex: '0x0186a0', _isBigNumber: true },
    to: '0x4200000000000000000000000000000000000010',
    value: BigNumber { _hex: '0x00', _isBigNumber: true },
    data: '0x32b7006d000000000000000000000000cb5ef4e9e72d0da950b9ffab92bf73723364e42c0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000de0b6b3a7640000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000800000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000',
    accessList: [],
    hash: '0x9e4c32a857ae09a59ea6368f9a49601b6202345d66a70fdd841fde1b307aa307',
    v: 0,
    r: '0x1a975ad488a53931601b05ea90f993df8130152ce425b56f3babaaa2a42476f5',
    s: '0x3d914837c3b9dee470cf3a077c08520d8c4697072e1cdc728ecd112afed7a2bf',
    from: '0xea048Dca261968abD942Ec9583dbb83b8ACF614E',
    confirmations: 0,
    wait: [Function (anonymous)]
  },
  receipt: {
    to: '0x4200000000000000000000000000000000000010',
    from: '0xea048Dca261968abD942Ec9583dbb83b8ACF614E',
    contractAddress: null,
    transactionIndex: 1,
    gasUsed: BigNumber { _hex: '0xa285', _isBigNumber: true },
    logsBloom: '0x00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000',
    blockHash: '0x0a88a79996ebef640d35500b039b0acac541be6481fcfb4d77e8d213c9aefe0f',
    transactionHash: '0x9e4c32a857ae09a59ea6368f9a49601b6202345d66a70fdd841fde1b307aa307',
    logs: [],
    blockNumber: 86090,
    confirmations: 1,
    cumulativeGasUsed: BigNumber { _hex: '0x014daf', _isBigNumber: true },
    effectiveGasPrice: BigNumber { _hex: '0x59682ffc', _isBigNumber: true },
    status: 0,
    type: 2,
    byzantium: true
  }
}

Any thoughts or something wrong you might have spotted?
Thank you!

[jsvisa]

I formatted your error log as below:

Error: transaction failed [ See: https://links.ethers.org/v5-errors-CALL_EXCEPTION ] (
transactionHash="0x9e4c32a857ae09a59ea6368f9a49601b6202345d66a70fdd841fde1b307aa307",
transaction={
  "type": 2,
  "chainId": 71936,
  "nonce": 26,
  "maxPriorityFeePerGas": { "type": "BigNumber", "hex": "0x59682f00" },
  "maxFeePerGas": { "type": "BigNumber", "hex": "0x596830f8" },
  "gasPrice": null,
  "gasLimit": { "type": "BigNumber", "hex": "0x0186a0" },
  "to": "0x4200000000000000000000000000000000000010",
  "value": { "type": "BigNumber", "hex": "0x00" },
  "data": "0x32b7006d000000000000000000000000cb5ef4e9e72d0da950b9ffab92bf73723364e42c0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000de0b6b3a7640000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000800000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
  "accessList": [],
  "hash": "0x9e4c32a857ae09a59ea6368f9a49601b6202345d66a70fdd841fde1b307aa307",
  "v": 0,
  "r": "0x1a975ad488a53931601b05ea90f993df8130152ce425b56f3babaaa2a42476f5",
  "s": "0x3d914837c3b9dee470cf3a077c08520d8c4697072e1cdc728ecd112afed7a2bf",
  "from": "0xea048Dca261968abD942Ec9583dbb83b8ACF614E",
  "confirmations": 0
},
receipt={
  "to": "0x4200000000000000000000000000000000000010",
  "from": "0xea048Dca261968abD942Ec9583dbb83b8ACF614E",
  "contractAddress": null,
  "transactionIndex": 1,
  "gasUsed": { "type": "BigNumber", "hex": "0xa285" },
  "logsBloom": "0x00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
  "blockHash": "0x0a88a79996ebef640d35500b039b0acac541be6481fcfb4d77e8d213c9aefe0f",
  "transactionHash": "0x9e4c32a857ae09a59ea6368f9a49601b6202345d66a70fdd841fde1b307aa307",
  "logs": [],
  "blockNumber": 86090,
  "confirmations": 1,
  "cumulativeGasUsed": { "type": "BigNumber", "hex": "0x014daf" },
  "effectiveGasPrice": { "type": "BigNumber", "hex": "0x59682ffc" },
  "status": 0,
  "type": 2,
  "byzantium": true
},
    code=CALL_EXCEPTION, version=providers/5.8.0)

Could you please take a look at why this tx 0x9e4c32a857ae09a59ea6368f9a49601b6202345d66a70fdd841fde1b307aa307 is failed, If you're running with op-geth as l2 execution client, you can try the debug_traceTransaction RPC, refer https://www.quicknode.com/docs/ethereum/debug_traceTransaction with callTracer:

{"method":"debug_traceTransaction","params":["0x9e4c32a857ae09a59ea6368f9a49601b6202345d66a70fdd841fde1b307aa307", {"tracer": "callTracer"}], "id":1,"jsonrpc":"2.0"}

[opfocus]

gasLimit: 100_000n, Why are you overwriting this value and have you tried removing the value. This seems too low

[tiagorvmartins]

If I dont, it was complaining around unpredictive gas limit error and to manually set it, how much you think would be reasonable to set to? Thank you @opfocus

[Chomtana]

Unpredictable gas limit indicate that contract code has some error and is reverted. Can you try deploy and withdrawal in OP sepolia so that we have a better debug tooling.

[opfocus]

I see that your chain seems to have stopped publishing the output root. If you haven't had time to try it recently, we'll close the question.
You can follow the documentation and issues in the documentation repository to learn about the latest viem support.

[tiagorvmartins]

Hey @Chomtana and @opfocus thank you for the fast replies, yes I have stopped that chain where I was conducting this tests,
I hope today to get back to this as soon as possible, possibly today and let you know where I stand and the results!

[opfocus]

I shared a process of using viem:
#17 (comment)
and apply viem to own op stack tesnet
ethereum-optimism/docs#1473
Overall it is still more convenient to use optimism sdk

[opfocus]

I will close this discussion temporarily, you can still add replies